24 August 2009

And for my last act, I will review this book...

The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox (Maggie O’Farrell)


This book is a tangled juxtaposition of multiple perspectives, including the title character Esme Lennox, great-aunt to Iris Lockhart. Iris is juggling an affair and some long harbored feelings for her “adopted brother” Alex when she discovers her grandmother Kitty has a sister (enter: Esme). Esme's been out of the picture for 60 some odd years because she’s been locked away in a mental hospital, which is now closing. She is thus thrust into the care of her closest (and healthiest, as Kitty has Alzheimer’s) relative’s care. Are you following the plot so far? That’s just the tip of the iceberg. The rest of the book is about revealing why Esme was locked up and there is some interesting twists so I will go no further revealing the plot.

While I think the author intended this book to be a play on narrative form, at times it's kind of a mess to follow. There are multiple elements to each of Esme and Iris’ stories. Each could get their own sections to be explained but instead they are all mixed up. I felt like I was constantly jumping from the mind of Esme (both young and old), seeing the past and present world through her eyes, and then trying to read through the incomplete memories of Alzheimer’s Kitty, along with following the drama of Iris’s situation while she tries to absorb the knowledge of this new addition to her family. Because of this, I thought the characters were hard to empathize with and that only takes away from the ending, which in retrospect is intricate and intriguing.

The style of writing is eloquent. It reminds me of The Awakening, mixed with The Yellow Wall-Paper. The writer was clearly influenced by Chopin’s use of the sea as a metaphor and catalyst for her heroines. There’s also a Gothic-ness to the story, with the family secrets and issues of madness. Overall, it’s not terribly long, so I read through it in a couple sittings. If you enjoy Chopin, and Gothic literature, then you would probably enjoy this book. However, I would have preferred a steadier storyline with fewer jumps in time and perspective. B-

1 comment: